The Problem: Focus Only on the Final Product
In school exhibitions, teachers and judges often only praise the final product — the beautiful model, poster, robot, painting, etc. But…
Who made it? Was it really the student, or did a parent or someone else help too much?
How was it made? Did the student learn anything, or just assemble pieces without understanding?
Why was it made this way? What was the thinking behind it?
This way of evaluation ignores the heart of learning — the process.
🧠 Why the Process Matters More Than the Product
-
Learning Happens in the Process
Struggling, planning, testing, failing, trying again — this is where real learning happens, not just in painting the model nicely. -
Ownership and Originality
When we value only the final product, students feel pressure to make it perfect — and some may take help or even outsource it. But when we value their process, they feel proud of their own thinking and effort. -
Fairness
A student who made a simple model by themselves should be appreciated more than a student who brings a perfect one made by an adult. Only looking at the end result is not fair.
Example:
Two students bring a volcano model:
One is flashy, has lights, smoke, and labels — clearly made with adult help.
The other is made from clay and paper, with handwritten notes, and has small errors.
If we only praise the first one, we’re rewarding the polish — not the learning.
But if we ask questions like:
"How did you plan this?"
"What problems did you face?"
"What did you learn while making it?"
…then we discover that the second student maybe learned more and worked harder independently.
What Should Teachers Do Instead?
-
Ask for Journals or Reflection Notes
Let students explain what they did, what was hard, and how they solved problems. -
Value Rough Work & Drafts
Display process photos or sketches alongside the final product. -
Interview Students
During exhibitions, ask each student to explain their model — how it was made, why they chose certain materials, what they learned. -
Give Awards for Process
Not just "Best Model" — but also:
"Best Idea Development"
"Most Independent Work"
"Creative Use of Materials"
"Deepest Thinking"
If we want real learning, we must celebrate the thinking — not just the painting.
So yes, let’s shift the spotlight from the product to the process. That’s how we know what students really learned, and how we build confidence, honesty, and creativity in them.